| | | ONU wins the toss and defers. MC will receive and defend the S goal. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar35 | ONU ball on ONU35. |
| | | Dom DiFalco kickoff 65 yards to the MAR0, touchback. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar20 | MAR ball on MAR25. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar25 | Bryce Agnew rush for 3 yards to the MAR28 (Jarrett Sitton). |
| Mar | 2-7 | at Mar28 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Maguire Morris for 2 yards to the MAR30 (Jarrett Sitton;Josh Bever). |
| Mar | 3-5 | at Mar30 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Bryce Agnew for no gain to the MAR30 (Adonis Ables). |
| Mar | 4-5 | at Mar30 | Bailey Sprague punt 21 yards to the ONU49, out-of-bounds, PENALTY ONU personal foul 15 yards to the MAR45, 1ST DOWN MAR, NO PLAY. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar45 | Bryce Agnew rush for 1 yard to the MAR46 (Peyton Wilson;Jevon Taylor). |
| Mar | 2-9 | at Mar46 | Bryce Agnew rush for 5 yards to the ONU49 (Peyton Wilson). |
| Mar | 3-4 | at Onu49 | Logyn Ratliff rush for 5 yards to the ONU44, 1ST DOWN MAR (Adonis Ables). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu44 | Connor Vierstra pass incomplete. |
| Mar | 2-10 | at Onu44 | Bryce Agnew rush for 2 yards to the ONU42 (Peyton Wilson;Nichal Johnson). |
| Mar | 3-8 | at Onu42 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Bryce Agnew for 9 yards to the ONU33, 1ST DOWN MAR, out-of-bounds (Jarrett Sitton). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu33 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Austin Veatch for 11 yards to the ONU22, 1ST DOWN MAR (Jevon Taylor). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu22 | Bryce Agnew rush for no gain to the ONU22 (Johnny Rupp). |
| Mar | 2-10 | at Onu22 | Bryce Agnew rush for 2 yards to the ONU20 (Nichal Johnson). |
| Mar | 3-8 | at Onu20 | Logyn Ratliff rush for 3 yards to the ONU17 (Josh Bever;Ed Manning). |
| Mar | 4-5 | at Onu17 | Connor Vierstra pass incomplete. |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 58 yards, TOP 07:21 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu17 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 07:39. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu17 | Brock Martin rush for 5 yards to the ONU22 (Simon Schott). |
| Onu | 2-5 | at Onu22 | Brock Martin rush for 1 yard to the ONU23 (Simon Schott). |
| Onu | 3-4 | at Onu23 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Chase Rose for 3 yards to the ONU26, out-of-bounds (Tay Pryor). |
| Onu | 4-1 | at Onu26 | Aaron Everhart punt 34 yards to the MAR40, Austin Veatch return 19 yards to the ONU41, out-of-bounds (Collin Flynn). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:51 |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu41 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 05:48. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu41 | Bryce Agnew rush for 6 yards to the ONU35 (Trevon Salter). |
| Mar | 2-4 | at Onu35 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Logan Ranft for 5 yards to the ONU30, 1ST DOWN MAR (K. Woodfork;Trevon Salter). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu30 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Gage Giovengo for 3 yards to the ONU27 (Jevon Taylor;Johnny Rupp). |
| Mar | 2-7 | at Onu27 | Connor Vierstra pass incomplete. |
| Mar | 3-7 | at Onu27 | Connor Vierstra pass incomplete to Clay Mastin. |
| Mar | 4-7 | at Onu27 | Connor Vierstra pass incomplete, PENALTY ONU pass interference (Johnny Rupp) 6 yards to the ONU21, 1ST DOWN MAR, NO PLAY. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu21 | Bryce Agnew rush for 2 yards to the ONU19 (Jarrett Sitton;Nichal Johnson). |
| Mar | 2-8 | at Onu19 | Bryce Agnew rush for no gain to the ONU19 (Josh Bever). |
| Mar | 3-8 | at Onu19 | Connor Vierstra pass incomplete to Bryce Agnew. |
| Mar | 4-8 | at Onu19 | Matthew Haus field goal attempt from 36 MISSED - wide left, spot at ONU20, clock 02:19. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 22 yards, TOP 03:29 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu20 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 02:19. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu20 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Jack DiMario for 31 yards to the MAR49, 1ST DOWN ONU (Darius Hatch). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar49 | Brody Hahn rush for 4 yards to the MAR45 (Kyler Folkert). |
| Onu | 2-6 | at Mar45 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Noah Miller for 3 yards to the MAR42 (Malik Grier;Quiero-Gordon). |
| Onu | 3-3 | at Mar42 | Brock Martin rush for 14 yards to the MAR28, 1ST DOWN ONU (Malik Grier;Tay Pryor). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar28 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Austin Eick for 4 yards to the MAR24 (Tay Pryor). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 56 yards, TOP 04:33 |
| | | Marietta College 0, Ohio Northern 0 |
| Onu | 2-6 | at Mar24 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Onu | 2-6 | at Mar24 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Chase Rose (Tay Pryor). |
| Onu | 3-6 | at Mar24 | Brody Hahn rush for 6 yards to the MAR18, 1ST DOWN ONU, out-of-bounds (Kyler Folkert). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar18 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Chase Rose for 3 yards to the MAR15 (Quiero-Gordon). |
| Onu | 2-7 | at Mar15 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Brock Martin for 10 yards to the MAR5, 1ST DOWN ONU (Vic Giovengo;Darius Hatch). |
| Onu | 1-G | at Mar05 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Noah Miller. |
| Onu | 2-G | at Mar05 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete (K. Gallagher). |
| Onu | 3-G | at Mar05 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to James McDougald. |
| Onu | 4-G | at Mar05 | Dom DiFalco field goal attempt from 22 GOOD, clock 12:51. |
| | | Ohio Northern 3, Marietta College 0 |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 75 yards, TOP 04:33 |
| | | Dom DiFalco kickoff 58 yards to the MAR7, Darius Hatch return 18 yards to the MAR25 (Nick Hawk). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar25 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 12:46. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar25 | Bryce Agnew rush for 3 yards to the MAR28 (K. Woodfork;Johnny Rupp). |
| Mar | 2-7 | at Mar28 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Dre Baldwin for 16 yards to the MAR44, 1ST DOWN MAR (Johnny Rupp). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar44 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Dre Baldwin for 8 yards to the ONU48, out-of-bounds (Jevon Taylor). |
| Mar | 2-2 | at Onu48 | Bryce Agnew rush for 4 yards to the ONU44, 1ST DOWN MAR (Justin Taylor). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu44 | Logyn Ratliff rush for 6 yards to the ONU38 (Johnny Rupp). |
| Mar | 2-4 | at Onu38 | Logyn Ratliff pass complete to Logan Ranft for 38 yards to the ONU0, 1ST DOWN MAR, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:27. |
| | | Matthew Haus kick attempt good. |
| | | Marietta College 7, Ohio Northern 3 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 75 yards, TOP 03:25 |
| | | Matthew Haus kickoff 60 yards to the ONU5, L.J. Payton return 20 yards to the ONU25 (Frank Sciury). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu25 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 09:21. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu25 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Chase Rose for 61 yards to the MAR14, 1ST DOWN ONU (Darius Hatch). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar14 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Jack DiMario, PENALTY ONU holding (Aidan Thompson) 10 yards to the MAR24, NO PLAY. |
| Onu | 1-20 | at Mar24 | Brock Martin rush for 1 yard to the MAR23 (K. Gallagher;Kyler Folkert). |
| Onu | 2-19 | at Mar23 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Jack DiMario (Tay Pryor). |
| Onu | 3-19 | at Mar23 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to L.J. Payton (Vic Giovengo). |
| Onu | 4-19 | at Mar23 | Dom DiFalco field goal attempt from 40 MISSED - wide right, spot at MAR23, clock 07:48. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 52 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar23 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 07:48. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar23 | Bryce Agnew rush for 3 yards to the MAR26 (Josh Bever;Jarrett Sitton). |
| Mar | 2-7 | at Mar26 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Gage Giovengo for 6 yards to the MAR32, out-of-bounds (Peyton Wilson). |
| Mar | 3-1 | at Mar32 | Bryce Agnew rush for 28 yards to the ONU40, 1ST DOWN MAR, out-of-bounds (Dalton Tjong). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu40 | Connor Vierstra pass incomplete to Logan Ranft (Nate Dean). |
| Mar | 2-10 | at Onu40 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Hayden Tanner for no gain to the ONU40. |
| Mar | 3-10 | at Onu40 | Hayden Tanner rush for loss of 1 yard to the ONU41 (Tyler Irigoyen). |
| Mar | 4-11 | at Onu41 | Bailey Sprague punt 41 yards to the ONU0, touchback, PENALTY ONU roughing the kicker 5 yards to the ONU36, NO PLAY. |
| Mar | 4-6 | at Onu36 | Bailey Sprague punt 36 yards to the ONU0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 41 yards, TOP 03:44 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu20 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 04:04. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu20 | Brock Martin rush for 9 yards to the ONU29 (Malik Grier). |
| Onu | 2-1 | at Onu29 | Brody Hahn sacked for loss of 5 yards to the ONU24 (Drake Neuberger). |
| Onu | 3-6 | at Onu24 | Timeout Ohio Northern, clock 02:44. |
| Onu | 3-6 | at Onu24 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Austin Eick for 13 yards to the ONU37, 1ST DOWN ONU (Malik Grier;Vic Giovengo). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu37 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete. |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Onu37 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Chase Rose, dropped pass, PENALTY ONU pass interference (Austin Eick) 15 yards to the ONU22, NO PLAY. |
| Onu | 2-25 | at Onu22 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Brock Martin for 9 yards to the ONU31, out-of-bounds (Luke Watt). |
| Onu | 3-16 | at Onu31 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Austin Eick (Tay Pryor), PENALTY MAR pass interference (Tay Pryor) 15 yards to the ONU46, 1ST DOWN ONU, NO PLAY. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu46 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Austin Eick. |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Onu46 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to L.J. Payton. |
| Onu | 3-10 | at Onu46 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Jack DiMario for 54 yards to the MAR0, 1ST DOWN ONU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:27. |
| | | Dom DiFalco kick attempt good. |
| | | Ohio Northern 10, Marietta College 7 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 80 yards, TOP 02:38 |
| | | Dom DiFalco kickoff 40 yards to the MAR25, on-side kick, recovered by ONU on MAR25. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar25 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 01:26. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar25 | Brody Hahn rush for 1 yard to the MAR24, out-of-bounds (Vic Giovengo). |
| Onu | 2-9 | at Mar24 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Chase Rose for 19 yards to the MAR5, 1ST DOWN ONU (Malik Grier;Quiero-Gordon). |
| Onu | 1-G | at Mar05 | Brock Martin rush for loss of 1 yard to the MAR6 (Drake Neuberger). |
| Onu | 2-G | at Mar06 | Timeout Ohio Northern, clock 00:38. |
| Onu | 2-G | at Mar06 | Brody Hahn rush for loss of 3 yards to the MAR9, out-of-bounds (Malik Grier). |
| Onu | 3-G | at Mar09 | Timeout Marietta College, clock 00:33. |
| Onu | 3-G | at Mar09 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Austin Eick for 9 yards to the MAR0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:27. |
| | | Dom DiFalco kick attempt good. |
| | | Ohio Northern 17, Marietta College 7 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 25 yards, TOP 01:03 |
| | | Dom DiFalco kickoff 54 yards to the MAR11, Dawson Snyder return 12 yards to the MAR23 (Braedon Gedeon), PENALTY MAR holding (S. Sinophat) 10 yards to the MAR13, 1st and 10, MAR ball on MAR13. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar13 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 00:23. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar13 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the MAR12. |
| Mar | 2-11 | at Mar12 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:23 |
| | | Ohio Northern 17, Marietta College 7 |
| Mar | 2-11 | at Mar12 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, MAR ball on MAR35. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:23 |
| | | Matthew Haus kickoff 60 yards to the ONU5, Jordan Dean return 22 yards to the ONU27 (A. Wardzinski). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu27 | Brock Martin rush for 5 yards to the ONU32 (K. Gallagher). |
| Onu | 2-5 | at Onu32 | Brock Martin rush for loss of 2 yards to the ONU30 (K. Gallagher). |
| Onu | 3-7 | at Onu30 | Brody Hahn sacked for loss of 3 yards to the ONU27 (Drake Neuberger). |
| | | The game is under a lightning delay at 3:07 pm. |
| | | Play will resume after a 40-minute delay at 3:47 pm. |
| Onu | 4-10 | at Onu27 | Aaron Everhart punt 36 yards to the MAR37, Austin Veatch return 7 yards to the MAR44, out-of-bounds (Jarrett Sitton). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 01:57 |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar44 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 13:03. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar44 | Bryce Agnew rush for 1 yard to the MAR45 (Tyler Irigoyen;Jarrett Sitton). |
| Mar | 2-9 | at Mar45 | PENALTY MAR illegal procedure (Zac Turkowski) 5 yards to the MAR40. |
| Mar | 2-14 | at Mar40 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Bryce Agnew for 17 yards to the ONU43, 1ST DOWN MAR, out-of-bounds (Peyton Wilson). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu43 | Connor Vierstra pass incomplete to Clay Mastin (Nate Dean), PENALTY ONU pass interference (Nate Dean) 15 yards to the ONU28, 1ST DOWN MAR, NO PLAY. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu28 | Bryce Agnew rush for 7 yards to the ONU21 (Elijah Harris;Trevon Salter). |
| Mar | 2-3 | at Onu21 | Bryce Agnew rush for 1 yard to the ONU20 (Josh Bever). |
| Mar | 3-2 | at Onu20 | Bryce Agnew rush for 9 yards to the ONU11, 1ST DOWN MAR (Jevon Taylor;Elijah Harris). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu11 | Bryce Agnew rush for 11 yards to the ONU0, 1ST DOWN MAR, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:00. |
| | | Matthew Haus kick attempt failed. |
| | | Ohio Northern 17, Marietta College 13 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 56 yards, TOP 03:07 |
| | | Matthew Haus kickoff 30 yards to the ONU35, Nick Hawk return 10 yards to the ONU45 (Hayden Tanner;Frank Sciury), PENALTY MAR offside 5 yards to the 50 yardline, 1st and 10, ONU ball on 50 yardline. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu50 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 09:56. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu50 | Brock Martin rush for 4 yards to the MAR46 (Drake Neuberger). |
| Onu | 2-6 | at Mar46 | Brock Martin rush for 3 yards to the MAR43 (Luke Watt;Simon Schott). |
| Onu | 3-3 | at Mar43 | Brody Hahn rush for 4 yards to the MAR39, 1ST DOWN ONU (Vic Giovengo). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar39 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete. |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Mar39 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Jack DiMario, dropped pass. |
| Onu | 3-10 | at Mar39 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Jack DiMario (Quiero-Gordon). |
| Onu | 4-10 | at Mar39 | Aaron Everhart punt 39 yards to the MAR0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 11 yards, TOP 01:59 |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar20 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 07:57. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar20 | Logyn Ratliff rush for 3 yards to the MAR23 (Jarrett Sitton). |
| Mar | 2-7 | at Mar23 | Connor Vierstra sacked for loss of 6 yards to the MAR17 (Josh Bever). |
| Mar | 3-13 | at Mar17 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Bryce Agnew for 83 yards to the ONU0, 1ST DOWN MAR, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:15. |
| | | Matthew Haus kick attempt good. |
| | | Marietta College 20, Ohio Northern 17 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 80 yards, TOP 01:48 |
| | | Matthew Haus kickoff 59 yards to the ONU6, L.J. Payton return 14 yards to the ONU20 (Hayden Tanner;Frank Sciury). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu20 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 06:09. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu20 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Austin Eick for 80 yards to the MAR0, 1ST DOWN ONU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:57. |
| | | Dom DiFalco kick attempt good. |
| | | Ohio Northern 24, Marietta College 20 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 80 yards, TOP 00:17 |
| | | Dom DiFalco kickoff 55 yards to the MAR10, Hayden Tanner return 21 yards to the MAR31 (Gianni McCrea). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar31 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 05:52. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar31 | Bryce Agnew rush for 5 yards to the MAR36 (Josh Bever). |
| Mar | 2-5 | at Mar36 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Austin Veatch for 27 yards to the ONU37, 1ST DOWN MAR (Ed Manning). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu37 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Maguire Morris for 7 yards to the ONU30, out-of-bounds (Dalton Tjong). |
| Mar | 2-3 | at Onu30 | Connor Vierstra rush for 2 yards to the ONU28 (Ed Manning;Trevon Salter). |
| Mar | 3-1 | at Onu28 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Logan Ranft for 28 yards to the ONU0, 1ST DOWN MAR, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:48. |
| | | Matthew Haus kick attempt good. |
| | | Marietta College 27, Ohio Northern 24 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 69 yards, TOP 02:10 |
| | | Matthew Haus kickoff 59 yards to the ONU6, L.J. Payton return 19 yards to the ONU25, fumble forced by A. Wardzinski, fumble by L.J. Payton recovered by ONU Nick Hawk at ONU25. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu25 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 03:42. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu25 | Brock Martin rush for no gain to the ONU25 (Kyler Folkert;Jesse Berzonski). |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Onu25 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Austin Eick for 8 yards to the ONU33, out-of-bounds (Tay Pryor). |
| Onu | 3-2 | at Onu33 | Brock Martin rush for 1 yard to the ONU34 (Jesse Berzonski;Mahleek Melton). |
| Onu | 4-1 | at Onu34 | Brock Martin rush for no gain to the ONU34 (Jesse Berzonski). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:57 |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu34 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 01:45. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu34 | Logyn Ratliff pass incomplete to Logan Ranft (Nate Dean). |
| Mar | 2-10 | at Onu34 | Bryce Agnew rush for 5 yards to the ONU29 (Peyton Wilson;Josh Bever). |
| Mar | 3-5 | at Onu29 | Bryce Agnew rush for 1 yard to the ONU28 (Peyton Wilson;Dalton Tjong). |
| Mar | 4-4 | at Onu28 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Gage Giovengo for 6 yards to the ONU22, 1ST DOWN MAR. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 12 yards, TOP 05:24 |
| | | Marietta College 27, Ohio Northern 24 |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu22 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu22 | Gage Giovengo rush for loss of 4 yards to the ONU26. |
| Mar | 2-14 | at Onu26 | Bryce Agnew rush for 6 yards to the ONU20 (Dalton Tjong;Collin Flynn). |
| Mar | 3-8 | at Onu20 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Austin Veatch for 8 yards to the ONU12, 1ST DOWN MAR (Dalton Tjong). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu12 | Bryce Agnew rush for 2 yards to the ONU10 (Jarrett Sitton;Nichal Johnson). |
| Mar | 2-8 | at Onu10 | Bryce Agnew rush for 5 yards to the ONU5 (Peyton Wilson;Jevon Taylor). |
| Mar | 3-3 | at Onu05 | Connor Vierstra rush for 4 yards to the ONU1, 1ST DOWN MAR (Jarrett Sitton;Collin Flynn), PENALTY ONU unsportsmanlike conduct (Jarrett Sitton) 0 yards to the ONU1. |
| Mar | 1-G | at Onu01 | 1st and 1. |
| Mar | 1-G | at Onu01 | Connor Vierstra rush for 1 yard to the ONU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:27. |
| | | Matthew Haus kick attempt failed. |
| | | Marietta College 33, Ohio Northern 24 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 34 yards, TOP 05:24 |
| | | Matthew Haus kickoff 52 yards to the ONU13, L.J. Payton return 12 yards to the ONU25 (A. Wardzinski). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu25 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 11:21. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu25 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Brock Martin for loss of 3 yards to the ONU22 (Kyler Folkert). |
| Onu | 2-13 | at Onu22 | PENALTY ONU false start (Cordell Wyatt) 5 yards to the ONU17. |
| Onu | 2-18 | at Onu17 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Chase Rose. |
| Onu | 3-18 | at Onu17 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Chase Rose for 33 yards to the 50 yardline, fumble forced by Ty'reik Martin, fumble by Chase Rose recovered by ONU TEAM at 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN ONU. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu50 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete. |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Onu50 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Jack DiMario for 21 yards to the MAR29, 1ST DOWN ONU (Malik Grier;Vic Giovengo). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar29 | Brody Hahn rush for 6 yards to the MAR23 (Kyler Folkert). |
| Onu | 2-4 | at Mar23 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Austin Eick. |
| Onu | 3-4 | at Mar23 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Austin Eick, dropped pass. |
| Onu | 4-4 | at Mar23 | Dom DiFalco field goal attempt from 40 GOOD, clock 08:33. |
| | | Marietta College 33, Ohio Northern 27 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 52 yards, TOP 02:48 |
| | | Dom DiFalco kickoff 65 yards to the MAR0, touchback. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar20 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 08:33. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar20 | MAR ball on MAR25. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar25 | Bryce Agnew rush for 2 yards to the MAR27 (Josh Bever;Johnny Rupp). |
| Mar | 2-8 | at Mar27 | Bryce Agnew rush for 5 yards to the MAR32 (Johnny Rupp). |
| Mar | 3-3 | at Mar32 | Connor Vierstra pass intercepted by Jevon Taylor at the MAR49, Jevon Taylor return 0 yards to the MAR49. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar49 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 07:03. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar49 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Chase Rose for 10 yards to the MAR39, 1ST DOWN ONU, out-of-bounds (Vic Giovengo). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar39 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Chase Rose for 21 yards to the MAR18, 1ST DOWN ONU (Darius Hatch), PENALTY MAR pass interference declined. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar18 | Brody Hahn pass complete to James McDougald for 8 yards to the MAR10 (Kyler Folkert;Vic Giovengo). |
| Onu | 2-2 | at Mar10 | PENALTY ONU illegal procedure (Zach George) 5 yards to the MAR15. |
| Onu | 2-7 | at Mar15 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Jack DiMario, dropped pass. |
| Onu | 3-7 | at Mar15 | Brody Hahn sacked for loss of 7 yards to the MAR22 (K. Gallagher). |
| Onu | 4-14 | at Mar22 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Jack DiMario (Malik Grier). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 27 yards, TOP 02:31 |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar22 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 04:32. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar22 | Bryce Agnew rush for no gain to the MAR22 (Nichal Johnson). |
| Mar | 2-10 | at Mar22 | Bryce Agnew rush for 19 yards to the MAR41, 1ST DOWN MAR, out-of-bounds (Peyton Wilson). |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar41 | Bryce Agnew rush for 4 yards to the MAR45 (Tyler Irigoyen;Johnny Rupp). |
| Mar | 2-6 | at Mar45 | Bryce Agnew rush for 4 yards to the MAR49 (Josh Bever;Collin Flynn). |
| Mar | 3-2 | at Mar49 | Bryce Agnew rush for 3 yards to the ONU48 (Jarrett Sitton;Peyton Wilson), PENALTY MAR illegal shift 5 yards to the MAR44, NO PLAY. |
| Mar | 3-7 | at Mar44 | Timeout Marietta College, clock 01:26. |
| Mar | 3-7 | at Mar44 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Maguire Morris for 21 yards to the ONU35, 1ST DOWN MAR, out-of-bounds. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Onu35 | Bryce Agnew rush for 2 yards to the ONU33 (Johnny Rupp;K. Woodfork). |
| Mar | 2-8 | at Onu33 | Timeout Ohio Northern, clock 01:14. |
| Mar | 2-8 | at Onu33 | Bryce Agnew rush for no gain to the ONU33 (Josh Bever). |
| Mar | 3-8 | at Onu33 | Timeout Ohio Northern, clock 01:09. |
| Mar | 3-8 | at Onu33 | Connor Vierstra rush for 1 yard to the ONU32 (Peyton Wilson;Nate Dean). |
| Mar | 4-7 | at Onu32 | Timeout Ohio Northern, clock 01:03. |
| Mar | 4-7 | at Onu32 | Connor Vierstra pass incomplete to Austin Veatch. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 46 yards, TOP 03:35 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu32 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 00:57. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu32 | Brody Hahn pass complete to James McDougald for 9 yards to the ONU41, out-of-bounds. |
| Onu | 2-1 | at Onu41 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Jack DiMario. |
| Onu | 3-1 | at Onu41 | Brody Hahn pass complete to James McDougald for 8 yards to the ONU49, 1ST DOWN ONU, out-of-bounds (Darius Hatch). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu49 | Brody Hahn pass complete to James McDougald for 18 yards to the MAR33, 1ST DOWN ONU, out-of-bounds (Quiero-Gordon). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Mar33 | Brody Hahn rush for 24 yards to the MAR9, 1ST DOWN ONU, out-of-bounds (Darius Hatch). |
| Onu | 1-G | at Mar09 | Brody Hahn pass incomplete to Austin Eick. |
| Onu | 2-G | at Mar09 | Brody Hahn pass complete to Austin Eick for 9 yards to the MAR0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:18. |
| | | Dom DiFalco kick attempt good. |
| | | Ohio Northern 34, Marietta College 33 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 68 yards, TOP 00:39 |
| | | Dom DiFalco kickoff 65 yards to the MAR0, touchback. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar20 | MARIETTA COLLEGE drive start at 00:18. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar20 | MAR ball on MAR25. |
| Mar | 1-10 | at Mar25 | PENALTY MAR delay of game 5 yards to the MAR20. |
| Mar | 1-15 | at Mar20 | Connor Vierstra pass complete to Maguire Morris for 7 yards to the MAR27, out-of-bounds (Elijah Harris). |
| Mar | 2-8 | at Mar27 | Connor Vierstra pass intercepted by Ed Manning at the ONU47, Ed Manning return 0 yards to the ONU47 (Logan Ranft), PENALTY ONU unsportsmanlike conduct (Jevon Taylor) 15 yards to the ONU32, 1st and 10, ONU ball on ONU32. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 2 yards, TOP 00:12 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu32 | OHIO NORTHERN drive start at 00:06. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu32 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the ONU31. |
| Onu | 2-11 | at Onu31 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:06 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Ohio Northern 34, Marietta College 33 |